Ukraine: Ukrainian Court Edict - International Arbitration Court Decisions - 3rd Edition
Originally from International Arbitration Court Decisions - 3rd Edition
UKRAINE COURT RECOMMENDATIONS IN DECEMBER 2007 BY THE PRESIDIUM OF THE HIGHEST COMMERCIAL COURT OF UKRAINE
“Ukrainian Court Edict”
Subject matters:
(1) Activities of and corporate relations concerning a Ukrainian joint stock company shall be governed exclusively by the laws of Ukraine.
(2) Agreements providing for the application of foreign law to Ukrainian corporate relationships including the relationships between shareholders are null and void and violate Ukrainian public policy.
(3) Agreements limiting the scope or effect of Ukrainian mandatory legal provisions (such as competition law and rules regarding the invalidity of agreements) are null and void.
(4) Shareholders’ agreements, even under foreign law and entered into by, for instance, non-Ukrainian holding companies cannot govern questions of corporate governance in a Ukrainian company and, hence, cannot be enforced to the extent they are at variance with Ukrainian company law.
(5) The Recommendations seek to exclude Ukrainian corporate disputes from determination by international arbitration (paragraph 2 of Section 6.2).
PRESIDIUM OF THE HIGHEST COMMERCIAL COURT OF UKRAINE RECOMMENDATIONS dated 28 Dec. 2007 No. 04-5/14
[To] Commercial courts of Ukraine
On application of legislation in deciding cases arising out of corporate relations
For the purposes of uniform and correct application of substantive and procedural law in deciding cases arising out of corporate relations, the Presidium of the Highest Commercial Court of Ukraine considers it necessary to provide the following recommendations.
UKRAINE
Court Recommendations in December 2007 by the Presidium of the Highest Commercial Court of Ukraine ("Ukrainian Court Edict")
SUBJECT-MATTER:
(1) Activities of and corporate relations concerning a Ukrainian joint stock company shall be governed exclusively by the laws of Ukraine.
(2) Agreements providing for the application of foreign law to Ukrainian corporate relationships including the relationships between shareholders are null and void and violate Ukrainian public policy.
(3) Agreements limiting the scope or effect of Ukrainian mandatory legal provisions (such as competition law and rules regarding the invalidity of agreements) are null and void.
(4) Shareholders' agreements, even under foreign law and entered into by, for instance, non-Ukrainian holding companies cannot govern questions of corporate governance in a Ukrainian company and, hence, cannot be enforced to the extent they are at variance with Ukrainian company law.
(5) The Recommendations seek to exclude Ukrainian corporate disputes from determination by international arbitration (paragraph 2 of Section 6.2).
Observations by Serhii Sviriba and Olga Glukhovska
Observations by Tatiana Slipachuk and Per Runeland
Observations by Alexander Vaneev