Sweden: Republic of Kazakhstan v. MTR Metals Ltd. (Cyprus) - International Arbitration Court Decisions - 3rd Edition
Originally from International Arbitration Court Decisions - 3rd Edition
I. PARTIAL AWARD ON JURISDICTION & FINAL AWARD RENDERED IN 2001 IN SCC CASE 85/2000 AND
II. DECISION BY THE SVEA COURT OF APPEAL RENDERED ON 25 MAY 2004 IN CASE T 1361-01
I. The Arbitration
Subject-Matters:
(1) Jurisdiction of the arbitral tribunal; whether the agreement to arbitrate can be concluded from parties conduct before a state court.
(2) State immunity as a bar to arbitration?
(3) Issue of succession of parties.
Findings:
(1) A declaration by a party before a state court that a claim which had been brought against it should be referred to arbitration constituted an acceptance by that party to arbitrate.
(2) Sovereign immunity was no obstacle to arbitral jurisdiction.
(3) The seller of the assets of a company owned by it was held responsible for the performance of the company’s obligations since the seller took possession and disposed of the company’s assets.
Parties:
Claimant: Republic of Kazakhstan
Respondent: MTR Metals Ltd. (Cyprus)
II. The Decision By the Svea Court of Appeal
Subject-Matters:
(1) Jurisdiction of the arbitral tribunal.
(2) Possible bias of the arbitral tribunal.
(3) One arbitrator excluded from the deliberations?
SWEDEN
Republic of Kazakhstan v. MTR Metals Ltd. (Cyprus), I. Partial Award on Jurisdiction & Final Award rendered in 2001 in SCC case 85/2000 & MTR Metals Ltd. (Cyprus) v. Republic of Kazakhstan, II. Decision by the Svea Court of Appeal rendered on 25 May 2004 in case T 1361-01
I. SUBJECT-MATTER(S):
(1) Jurisdiction of the arbitral tribunal; whether the agreement to arbitrate can be concluded from parties conduct before a state court.
(2) State immunity as a bar to arbitration?
(3) Issue of succession of parties.
II. SUBJECT-MATTERS:
(1) Jurisdiction of the arbitral tribunal.
(2) Possible bias of the arbitral tribunal.
(3) One arbitrator excluded from the deliberations?
Observations by Kendall Moholitny
Observations by Ola Åhman