Mediating Whistleblower Disputes: Integrating the Emotional and Legal Challenges - Chapter 72 - AAA Handbook on Mediation - Third Edition
Author(s):
Richard D. Fincher
Page Count:
15 pages
Published:
April, 2016
Jurisdictions:
Practice Areas:
Author Detail:
Richard Fincher is a full-time Mediator and Arbitrator of workplace disputes. He serves on the commercial mediation, employment arbitration, and mass claims panels of the American Arbitration Association and has arbitrated over 1,000 matters over the course of his career. A former national vice president at the Association for Conflict Resolution, Mr. Fincher teaches at the Scheinman Institute for Conflict Resolution at Cornell University. He can be reach at 602-953-5322 or by e-mail at rdf@workplaceresolutions.com
Description:
Originally from:
MEDIATING WHISTLEBLOWER DISPUTES: INTEGRATING THE EMOTIONAL AND LEGAL CHALLENGES
Richard D. Fincher
In 2002, three highly visible whistleblowers became Time Magazine’s “People of the Year.” They were Sherron Watkins of Enron, Cynthia Coopers of WorldCom, and FBI Special Agent Coleen Rowley. Each was a direct participant in exposing scandals in her organization. Their media status—along with the recent Sarbanes-Oxley statute—reshaped the American view of whistleblowers and encouraged more employees to come forward when employers retaliate against them.
This article first provides an overview of statutory whistleblower protections and the specifics of several whistleblower laws. Next it discusses using voluntary mediation to resolve these disputes, which in most cases takes place after a legal action is commenced alleging employer retaliation. In addition, it discusses some unique aspects of whistleblower mediation, including the need for even more than the usual amount of patience and sensitivity to the claimant’s emotions.
I. Who Are Whistleblowers?
Employees who believe they have uncovered unlawful conduct by their employer have four choices: remain silent, resign to distance themselves from the unlawful activity, report their concerns to the employer, or go public. Those who take either of the last two routes are considered whistleblowers. In general, there are three types of employees who become whistleblowers: senior executives (e.g., vice presidents, company attorneys), professionals (e.g., quality control technicians, training instructors, engineers and human resource managers), and hourly workers (e.g., electricians and maintenance workers).